1. Home
  2. Autos
  3. Cars

2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Sedan Test Drive
How does it look? It's got a great personality!

About.com Rating 4

From Jason Fogelson, for About.com

Picture of 2005 Subaru Legacy GT

It's the nose (hood) I don't really like. But looks aren't everything... really.

Jason Fogelson
Compare Prices
I admit it. I'm a juvenile. I love a good turbo, and the 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Sedan has a great one. Add a slick 5 speed manual, standard all-wheel drive, a 3 year/36,000 mile basic warranty and a 5 year/60,000 mile powertrain warranty, and the 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Sedan starts to look like a bargain at a base price of $28,595 ($30,354 as tested). Perched between the crunchy granola Outback and the boy racer WRX in the Subaru lineup, the Legacy has charms all its own.

First Glance

So, I have this friend you should get to know. She's got a great personality, she's really fun, comfortable and a great performer. Looks? Well, she's got a great personality!

Okay, so the Legacy Sedan has kind of a funny looking nose. It's round, and a little bulbous, and it doesn't really fit with the rest of the body. There's a bump in the middle, an air intake that bulges the hood in the center.

The sides and back of the Legacy are more linear, with straighter lines running front to rear and big, functional tail lights and a flat deck lid. The optional spoiler and Atlantic Blue Pearl paint ($380) were well applied, and there's a definite feeling of quality construction from stem to stern. The projector style headlights are high-tech looking, and sleekly enclosed behind plexi covers.

The individual pieces may work well, but put them together the result is underwhelming. It's not that the Legacy is an ugly car, because it isn't. It's just trapped in-between genres, with some of the unique styling of the Subaru family tempered by a more sedate, mature look. That might be a good thing, though, because you're going to want some stealth ability once you get this car moving on the road.

Like I said, she's got a great personality.

In the Driver's Seat

Picture of 2005 Subaru Legacy GT
The Legacy's clean dash is easy to use and understand.
Jason Fogelson
The first hint that the Legacy GT is something special comes when you sit down behind the wheel. This is a driver's car.

The supportive seat has an 8-way power adjustment, and the leather-wrapped Momo steering wheel is tilt-adjustable. It's easy to find a performance driving position. The instrument panel is clear and efficient, with big red needles sweeping across the tachometer and speedometer in the center of the cluster right above the wheel. Subaru has not cluttered the steering wheel with F1-style controls, choosing instead to add a lever behind the wheel for the cruise control switches.

The center stack of climate and radio controls features large buttons and dials, which are very easy to find and operate. A small compartment at the top of the center stack is just the right size for a cell phone and a pair of sunglasses, but a sticker inside warns that the compartment may get hot, so I'm not sure what you could actually keep in there safely -- certainly not candy bars. I'm not a big fan of fake wood, but the woodgrain accents on the dash pillars of the Legacy don't look half bad.

The power moonroof is a nice addition, especially the tilt-up feature that's great for letting in a little fresh air while burning up the road.

On the Road

There are cars that just beg to be driven fast, cars that taunt you to test the limits of your drivers license and insurance rate. The Legacy GT is one of those cars.

The 2.5 liter 4-cylinder boxer engine is turbocharged and cranks out 250 hp and 250 lb-ft of torque. That translates to rocket-like acceleration off the line, and great power throughout the rev range. If you like jackrabbit starts and cheetah bursts of power, you're going to love the Legacy GT.

In the old days of turbocharging, when you pressed down on the gas pedal you'd have to wait a second before the turbo pressure built up enough to produce power, and then it came on in a hurry. We called it "turbo lag," and it could be treacherous and hard to control. Subaru has tamed turbo lag, and the Legacy GT can be driven in a safe and sane manner (if you have self-control), while still taking advantage of the great performance.

The rest of the car is up to the challenge as well, with a firm suspension, great 4-wheel anti-lock disc brakes and Subaru's standard All-Wheel Driving System. The Legacy GT is capable of charging around corners and curves with abandon. This car is a siren, beckoning you to drive hard every time you get behind the wheel. It's a whole lot of fun.

Journey's End

Picture of 2005 Subaru Legacy GT
There's little in the way of visual cues that this is a fast car. But, let me tell you...
Jason Fogelson
My very first car was a Subaru, a used 1972 GL 1200 that I abused mercilessly while I was in high school. I gained a lot of respect for Subaru through my abuse. The old GL never let me down, no matter how badly I treated it. Subaru owners tend to be very loyal to the brand, and it's easy to see why.

The Legacy GT Sedan is a unique vehicle. It may not appeal to you at first glance, but it will make its case the second you drive it. The Legacy GT lineup also includes a Wagon, which I think is more attractive than the Sedan and adds utility for an upcharge of about $1000. The EPA estimates that you can expect 19 mpg city/25 mpg highway from the Legacy GT, though I'd expect the low end of the range if you drive with a lead foot like I do.

In terms of price, the Legacy is in the same league as the Audi A4, Saab 9-3 and Volvo S40; though it will blow the doors off of all of 'em. If you lust after a Mitsubishi Evo or Subaru WRX but can't see yourself surviving the punishment or the stares on a daily basis, the Subaru Legacy GT Sedan is a car to consider. You'll get a car you can drive hard without being pushed to your own limits.

If you agree that looks aren't everything, you can have a very fulfilling relationship with the Legacy GT.

Compare Prices
User Reviews Write Review
Explore Cars
About.com Special Features

Stay safe and save time by following these tips before driving a used car. More >

Discover the hottest cars for the 2010 calendar year. More >

  1. Home
  2. Autos
  3. Cars
  4. New Car Reviews
  5. Subaru
  6. 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Sedan - Test drive and new car review - 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Sedan

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.